Lives up to its hype! A great everyday lip liner!

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] This has a large following and for good reason. I'm late to the game - I received a full size of this pencil at Sephoria 2023 (NYC) but this summer has been the first time I've used it - I know!!! Sigh. Over the last 7+ weeks, I've used this lip pencil a couple of different ways & with several different lip products (lipstick, gloss, oil, balm) in a variety of shades.   TL;DR: It has the right mix of pink & brown for lining and filling in my slightly more naturally pigmented lips. A new favorite everyday lip liner. WHAT I LIKE: * Color and multi-use - 606 Wherever Walnut is a beautiful shade - the right combination of pink and brown for lining and filling in my slightly more naturally pigmented lips, which makes this a good liner for me to pair with practically every lip shade. 😍 * Creamy but not overly soft, making it easy to diffuse line with my finger and fill in lips * Leaves a demi-matte finish * Wears fairly comfortably on its own - does not make my lips feel dry or tight  * Longevity - it has decent staying power through sipping water, tea, coffee & light snacking (but see FYI) AREA(S) FOR IMPROVEMENT: * None, really, for me (but see FYI) * Not an area for improvement but a request - would love to see a value set (mini or full size) of the 5 shades the brand markets as "The Perfect Nude Liners". There may have been a previous set offered; would love to see it again, if that's the case. Perhaps for the holidays?  FYI:  * For a similar product with a longer wear time, waterproof formulation and a slightly more intense color, go for the Artist Color Extreme Waterproof version of this shade. * Pairs beautifully with the gloss of the same shade BUY, BUY, BUY 🛍️ or BYE-BYE 👋🏼?: * It'll take me a while before I'm close to finishing this so I won't need to buy one anytime soon. That being said, I would repurchase when I do use this up. I'd also be interested in picking up other shades. BUY 🛍️

Originally posted on sephora.com

Disappointing

Beautiful color, but does not last like it says it will. Used it as eyeliner (as it says you can) and within an hour it’s gone.

Originally posted on sephora.com