Best pencil eyeliner

These are the best pencil eyeliners I have found. They are a bit expensive for my budget. But they don’t fail throughout the day. I am an older woman and the black shades are too harsh. This gives a more natural look.

Originally posted on sephora.com

Not for me

I don't like waterproof products and this eyeliner is very hard to remove. I'd like to return it and get a washable eyeliner.

Originally posted on sephora.com