Fine for the price nothing more

Tested liner on my hand, my saliva took it right off ! Plain water did the same thing. I bought it anyway as I was looking for a lower priced liquid eyeliner. I bought it in Black and in Espresso, both looked rich in color. I don't need a waterproof liner but just the same... if it said WATERPROOF then it should be !

Originally posted on sephora.com

Very good , i love it , will buy it again , thank

Perfect eye liner , long lasting , deep dark black , good for sensitive eyes

Originally posted on sephora.com