Not smudge/transfer proof

I have the black and the brown. I being extremely lazy didn’t return them within the return window but nonetheless, the liners r cute, definitely pigmented but they smudge very easy. It always spreads around unfortunately so if you’re looking for something that’s transfer proof, I would save your money and maybe opt for either the Sephora eye pencil or Marc Jacob’s (they discontinued ) the one I loved but so far those r the ones that give u what you need.

Originally posted on sephora.com

The best

The best eyeliner I have used. So creamy & extremely pigmented. It’s easy to apply & looks amazing as well. I will never use another eyeliner.

Originally posted on sephora.com