Flakes more than a Gregg's sausage roll

Eventually got to try a sample small tube of this, and unfortunately not impressed! It flakes more than a Greggs sausage roll!! Was left with black specks around my eyes as the day wore on, I tried it with and without the SOS serum mascara as a base coat, and made no difference on staying power either way. I previously reviewed lamenting the lack of brown colour, like the fabulous previous 4D version, and I will say on the plus side, that this is not as intense a black as the other Clarins mascaras, I find it a more softer black, so a bit more flattering to wear. However as other reviewers have mentioned, it's very thin in consistency and takes a few coats to have any impact, and has nowhere near the same effect on lengthening & curling as the 4D. This, combined with the flakiness, it's a sad thumbs down for me. Will be eaking out my remaining 2 tubes of brown 4D.

Originally posted on clarins.co.uk

Horrible product

Messy useless product. I loved the 4D mascara, but this flakes, makes my lashes look stubby, does not lengthen them at all and I seem to get all over my eyelid! Unfortunately, due to Clarins useless tech I mistakenly ordered 3!

Originally posted on clarins.co.uk