Unlock your gifts
Complete Your Look
Reviews
Recent Reviews
Savannah
2
6/5/2026
Definitely not waterproof
Listen, I love the Tart Maneater mascara so much I was hoping to wear it for my wedding day, but I knew I would need the waterproof version, so I ordered this to test it out ahead of time. Cut to me wearing it regularly, only to breakdown in stressy wedding-planning tears with my fiance (iykyk), and he gets me a tissue because my mascara is running so bad. I asked him how quickly it started running/how bad it was and his response was just "Mulan. " -_- Not waterproof.
Originally posted on tartecosmetics.com
Shannon F.
5
4/28/2026
My favorite mascara
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I’ve tried several different brands and types of mascara and Maneater is the best! It doesn’t irritate my eyes, clump or smear.
Originally posted on tartecosmetics.com