Um Yes

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I’ve used this a handful of times now and I’m definitely impressed! I wear contacts and have sensitive eyes so mascara is a tricky subject for me. I can’t wear mascara for long periods of time before my eyes just become unbearable. The urge to scrub my makeup off gets intense. I was able to wear this without that feeling! I also love a thicker and “waxy” feeling to my mascaras. I don’t love when the formula feels thin or too “wet” lol. The shade of brown is absolutely perfect for day to day too. Soft but also still strong. Checks all the boxes for me!

Originally posted on sephora.com

Makes a mess!!

I actually like certain things about this mascara: I like the super black, I like the wand, it does not smudge or flake like so many other mascaras do. What I do not like: it does get clumpy after a while and I have to go in with a q-tip to remove the mess. And the absolute most annoying thing about this tube is that while the matte black container looks great, after a short while, the paint starts to flake off and makes a MESS everywhere! I have it on my hands, it's in the sink, my towel, I find flakes everywhere. I have to use a piece of toilet tissue to hold the applicator when I use it. It annoys me so much that I absolutely will not buy this mascara again unless they correct the problem. :(

Originally posted on sephora.com