Okay, but not flake/smudge proof

I'm having difficulty finding a tubing mascara that doesn't smudge or flake. This is better than some, but by the end of the day I have black specs under my eyes. So far Thrive is the only tubing mascara that works for me. I've also tried waterproof mascara and even that smudges. I assume it's b/c I have mature skin and wear eye cream.

نشر في الاصل بتاريخ sephora.com

Go to mascara

I started buying tubing mascaras a little over a year ago and have continuously bought this one in particular 5 times now.

نشر في الاصل بتاريخ sephora.com