Pass on this one

Gorgeous color but is really dry and doesn’t blend at all. Actually, its own brush takes away the color when you try to use it.

Originally posted on sephora.com

Pretty, but kind of useless.

Like almost every retractable eyeliner ever, the tip breaks. Not as badly as some cheap ones, but any breakage is annoying. It does not glide like the pencils do. I wish it did. I’m also personally not a fan of the slanted tip. To provide context, I have been using the 24/7 pencils for 20+ years. I’m not a “precision” type person…I like a line, but a kind of smudgy one. Lucky and Love Drug are my daily favorites. I was hoping this wouldn’t crumble. Once you get it going, it’s ok, but I don’t think it’s an improvement on the pencil with some kind of blending tool (brush or sponge-tip shadow applicator or q-tip). Not enough color payoff, either.

Originally posted on urbandecay.com