very smudgy

love mufe but this is definitely not waterproof/smudge-proof. if anything, this eyeliner is extra smudgy. super disappointed. i’ve even applied it on my arm, waited 30 minutes, and with a wipe with a (dry) finger it smudges. sad.

Originally posted on sephora.com

Unusable

I purchased this in a past version of the pencil. Mine has an unusable "sharpener" attached. I have no clue how the "sharpener" is to be used. Additionally, the pencil is not wood, but some other hard material that destroys the actual liner when I try to sharpen it with a regular makeup sharpener.

Originally posted on sephora.com