Unlock your gifts
Complete Your Look
Benefit Cosmetics
The brand behind Benetint, Hoola, BADgal BANG!, and probably your favorite brow brand! We believe that beauty should lift us up and make us feel good. Because feeling good is always a good look. So, whether you want a beauty solution you can trust or just need a good laugh, we've got your brows AND your back.
Shop Now
Reviews
Recent Reviews
Melanie
5
7/2/2026
Makes it easy
This is the best eyebrow pencil I’ve used - makes it effortless to get great brows
Originally posted on Sephora-uk
socalgal619
Verified Buyer
5
6/24/2026
My holy grail!
Absolutely LOVE this brow pencil!!! I started off purchasing the Precisely brow pencil from Benefit but it was so thin, it kept breaking on me with even the slightest pressure. I wasted so much product because of it and a full size pencil lasted MAYBE 2 weeks with daily use. Such a waste of money. I switched to this Goof Proof pencil and OMGosh, WHAT a difference. I have horrible brows thanks to over tweezing back in the day and this pencil gives me beautiful full and natural looking brows that last all day without smudging (and I have very oily skin). It goes on so smooth and thanks to its unique shape, it goes on very precise. Plus it lasts forever! One full size pencil lasts me 4-5 months with daily use! I will continue to repurchase it as long as they make it! It's fantastic!
Originally posted on sephora.com