Reviews
Recent Reviews
Thehalimator
Verified Buyer
1
11/18/2025
SAVE YOUR MONEY, Do NOT buy this
(This review was collected as part of a promotion.) DO NOT BUY. This thing is atrocious compared to their regular Mascaraa nd waterproof. I am a die hard MILK fan. But this is not itt. I understand people want a more 'cleaner' option, but MILK has not figured this one out yet. Cons: - It smears - Its just as annoying to get off as a waterproof one, my 2 makeup removes struggle - It does NOT make your lashes look lifted or volumizing. - Packaging feels cheap compared to their other two tubes, this ones a light plastic compared to the heavier metal feeling ones of the grey and blue tube - I will be returning this, i am so disappointed in this product. Pros: None. I hate this stuff.
Originally posted on sephora.com
roxyroxs2
Verified Buyer
1
11/16/2025
Do not buy! It smears so bad!
Do not buy this mascara!!!!! It smears so bad!!!!!!!!!! To make things worse, they didn’t want to accept my return because I passed the return date for 2 days!!! This mascara is horrible! Do Not waste your money!!!
Originally posted on sephora.com