not very brown

The "brown" seems more reddish to me. I was hoping for more "chocolate" like in the description but it isnt dark at all to me. Which is disappointing b/c the product is great otherwise!

Originally posted on sephora.com

I’ve been a return buyer on this one since it stays put and doesn’t irritate the eye, but it does dry up fast so I’m searching for a new brand

Originally posted on sephora.com