Unbelievably good

Crap. This might be the best eyeliner formula and shade I've ever tried. Doesn't go anywhere all day and glides on so smooth. I'll be buying a few more to stock up on

Originally posted on sephora.com

Not my fave

I wanted to love this but I found it didn’t apply very well. I had to reapply a few times to get it to look black. The tip seemed almost dry? The waterproof part is accurate though!

Originally posted on sephora.com