why such good reviews?

Like that the color is a rich black but that's all I can give it. One coat is alright, two is a clumpy mess. It flakes all over the place (even with one coat), doesn't hold a curl at all, and did nothing for lenthening my lashes. As others have stated, it was difficult to get off even with eye makeup remover.

Originally posted on sephora.com

This product really does what it says it will do. It makes my lashes really long.

Originally posted on sephora.com