Replacing my Bare Minerals clean liquid eyeliner

I was looking for a clean product to replace my discontinued Bare Minerals liquid eyeliner. This is the closest that I've found. I love the tip for its accuracy and fine line. It enables me to line close to my waterline. The only reason I'm giving it 4 stars is that it smudges on the lower lash line when the discontinued Bare Minerals liner did not. Also, the BM was waterproof and this one is not. I really like this liner and recommend it.

Originally posted on sephora.com

Nice, but I had an allergic reaction 

The pigmentation in this product is very nice. It stays on very well, but I got a really bad allergic reaction from it. 

Originally posted on sephora.com